New York Medicaid Fair Hearing for the Work Requirement
Your Right to a Hearing
If New York terminates or reduces your Medicaid coverage over the work requirement, you have the right to challenge that decision through a formal administrative fair hearing. The hearing is conducted by the Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance (OTDA), Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) — not by the same agency that made the original determination.
The critical deadlines:
- 60 days from the date of the agency action to file your hearing request
- Before the effective date in a timely advance notice to keep benefits active while the hearing is pending; a separate 10-day-from-mailing rule applies when notice was adequate but not timely
The aid-continuing deadline depends on the notice. A timely advance notice generally allows aid continuing if you request the hearing before its effective date. If notice was adequate but not timely, New York's separate 10-day rule may apply; aid continuing is unavailable when the sole issue is State or Federal law or policy.
How to File
You can request a hearing through these channels:
Online. Submit an electronic hearing request at otda.ny.gov/hearings.
Phone. Call the OTDA hearing hotline at 1-800-342-3334. This line also handles emergency expedited requests.
Fax. Send your written request to 518-473-6735.
Mail. NYS Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance, Office of Administrative Hearings, P.O. Box 1930, Albany, NY 12201-1930.
New York also accepts in-person requests. Contact OTDA or your local social services district for the appropriate office.
If you file by phone or online, you get immediate confirmation. Mail and fax are slower — if you are close to the 10-day deadline, file by phone first and follow up in writing.
Aid Continuing: Keep Your Benefits While You Wait
Requesting a hearing before the effective date in a timely advance notice generally triggers aid continuing. Where the notice was adequate but not timely, a separate 10-day-from-mailing rule may apply. When aid continuing applies, Medicaid stays active while OTDA processes the hearing.
If you miss the applicable aid-continuing deadline but request a hearing within the standard 60-day period, you may still get a hearing, but your benefits may end before the decision. If you win, the state restores coverage retroactively.
Free Download
Get the New York Medicaid Work Requirement Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
What to Bring to the Hearing
The burden is on the state to show it followed proper procedures. Your job is to present evidence that you either met the work requirement or qualified for an exemption.
Useful evidence:
- Paystubs or earnings records for the month the state says you were noncompliant
- Volunteer timesheets or supervisor letters with dates and hours
- School enrollment verification if you were a student
- Exemption documentation — medical records, birth certificates, caregiving statements
- Copies of anything you submitted to the state during the 30-day cure window, including portal upload confirmations, certified mail receipts, or mobile app transmission logs
- The state's own notices — bring every letter you received in the sequence
You have the right under 18 NYCRR §§ 358-3.4 and 358-3.7 to examine your case record and receive relevant hearing documents without charge before the hearing. Request your file when you file for the hearing so you have time to review it.
Representation
You can represent yourself — this is called appearing pro se. You can also bring an attorney, a legal advocate from a legal aid organization, or even a friend or relative, with written authorization under 18 NYCRR § 358-3.9.
If you need free legal help:
- Community Health Advocates (CHA): 1-888-614-5400 — statewide helpline offering coverage counseling and fair hearing support
- The Legal Aid Society (NYC): provides legal representation for Medicaid denials
- New York Legal Assistance Group (NYLAG): health law services
- Empire Justice Center: covers Western New York and Finger Lakes region
Free language interpreter services are required at all administrative hearings. If you need one, request it when you file.
Hearing Timeline
OTDA ordinarily must take final action within 90 days. If the usual timeframe could jeopardize your life, health, or ability to attain, maintain, or regain maximum function, you may request an expedited hearing. For an expedited eligibility claim, final action is due within seven working days; the three-working-day deadline applies to expedited services or benefits claims.
If you win, the state must comply with the hearing decision. If you lose, the limited 90-day reconsideration rule applies only in specified cases, including MAGI enrollees disenrolled for failing to submit information requested in a community-engagement notice; otherwise, you may reapply for Medicaid.
The New York Medicaid Work Requirement Guide includes a hearing preparation worksheet, a checklist of documents to gather, and a timeline of every deadline from the first noncompliance notice through the hearing decision.
Get Your Free New York Medicaid Work Requirement Checklist
Download the New York Medicaid Work Requirement Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.