$0 New York Medicaid Work Requirement Checklist

How to Respond to a New York Medicaid Noncompliance Notice in 30 Days

Starting January 1, 2027, if you get a letter from NY State of Health or your local department of social services saying the state could not verify that you met the Medicaid work requirement, it must give you a chance to respond before making a final eligibility decision. Here is what you need to do, in order, with the deadlines that matter.

The critical fact: the 30-day cure period and any appeal deadline are separate clocks. The 30 calendar days to show compliance or that the requirement does not apply begin when you receive the noncompliance notice. A later notice stopping or reducing coverage can trigger a separate appeal and continued-coverage deadline; the 10-day deadline does not run from the initial noncompliance notice.

The Two Deadlines

Deadline Clock Starts What It Does What Happens If You Miss It
30 calendar days to respond Date you receive the noncompliance notice; receipt is presumed 5 days after its date unless you show later receipt Show compliance or that the requirement does not apply The state may make an eligibility decision after the response period
Appeal and continued coverage after a later coverage-ending notice For NYSOH, the date of the later notice; for local DSS, the effective date in its notice For NYSOH, request continued coverage within 10 days of the date of the later notice; for local DSS, request a fair hearing before the effective date (or within 10 days of the postmark if the notice was not sent before that date) A hearing can still be requested within 60 days, but continued-coverage rules depend on the agency and timing

The 10-day deadline matters only if a later NYSOH notice says your coverage will stop or be reduced. If you think that decision is wrong — because documents were lost or you believe you qualify for an exemption — follow the appeal instructions on that notice and ask for continued coverage within 10 days of its date. For a local DSS action, follow the hearing deadline in that notice.

Step-by-Step: What to Do in Order

Day 1-2: Read the Notice and Identify the Problem

The notice states the specific reason for noncompliance. It is usually one of:

  • No hours reported — the state's automated check found no payroll data through Truv, and you did not submit manual documentation
  • Hours below 80 — the state recorded some activity but it did not reach the monthly threshold
  • No exemption on file — you may qualify for an exemption but it was not reported or the documentation was insufficient
  • Renewal lapse — your six-month renewal included a work requirement check and the system could not verify compliance for the lookback month

Identify which situation matches yours. This determines what you need to submit during the cure window.

Day 1-2: Decide Whether to Request Aid Continuing

If a later notice says your Medicaid coverage will stop or be reduced and you believe that decision is wrong — your documents were submitted but not processed, you qualify for an exemption the state did not apply, or the hours calculation is incorrect — request an appeal and ask for continued coverage.

How to request it: For a NYSOH decision, follow the appeal instructions on the notice or call NYSOH at 1-855-355-5777. Request continued coverage within 10 days of the date on the notice that stops or reduces Medicaid. For a local DSS decision, request a fair hearing through OTDA at 1-800-342-3334 before the effective date in the notice; if the notice was not sent before that date, request the hearing within 10 days of its postmark. Have your Medicaid case number and your NY Benefit Card ID ready.

Continued coverage can remain in place while an appeal is pending if you meet the applicable request deadline. The agency handling the decision and the date on its notice determine which rule applies.

Day 3-14: Gather Your Documentation

During the 30-day cure window, you can submit proof that you actually met the requirement. What you need depends on your situation:

If you worked 80+ hours but the state didn't record them:

  • Paystubs showing gross earnings and hours for the relevant month
  • Employer letter confirming hours worked (on company letterhead with supervisor contact)
  • Platform earnings summaries for gig workers (Uber, Lyft, DoorDash, etc.)
  • Bank statements showing deposits that corroborate earnings

If your MAGI-based household income meets the monthly income threshold (80 times the federal minimum wage, or $580 when the rate is $7.25):

  • Earnings and other records used to verify MAGI-based household income for the relevant month
  • For seasonal workers, records of MAGI-based household income over the preceding 6 months if the state does not use its MAGI reasonably predictable changes method

If you qualify for an exemption:

  • Parenting a child under 14: birth certificate or custody documentation, plus proof the child lives with you
  • Medical frailty: clinician statement describing the health condition and how it impairs capacity to meet the 80-hour requirement
  • Caregiving for a disabled individual: documentation of the person's disability and your caregiving arrangement
  • Student: registrar verification of at least half-time enrollment
  • Pregnancy: medical documentation of current pregnancy
  • Substance use disorder or mental health treatment: program enrollment verification

Day 14-25: Submit Through the Right Channel

Submit your satisfactory showing using the methods described in your notice. The notice must explain how you may submit the information and the deadline for doing so.

Do not submit work requirement documentation through ACCESS HRA if you are a MAGI enrollee. ACCESS HRA handles non-MAGI Medicaid and NYC public assistance cases. Documents uploaded to the wrong system do not transfer automatically.

After uploading, confirm receipt. Call NYSOH to verify the documents were received and associated with your case. Keep a record of the confirmation — the date, the representative's name if given, and the confirmation number.

Day 25-30: If the Cure Does Not Resolve It

If you submitted documentation but the state has not updated your status, or if you believe the determination is still wrong after submitting proof:

  1. Follow the appeal instructions on the notice. For a NYSOH decision, call NYSOH at 1-855-355-5777; for a local DSS decision, request a fair hearing through OTDA at 1-800-342-3334
  2. Contact Community Health Advocates at 1-888-614-5400 for free assistance with the hearing process
  3. In NYC, contact The Legal Aid Society at 1-888-663-6880 or the New York Legal Assistance Group (NYLAG)
  4. Empire Justice Center provides statewide assistance with Medicaid fair hearings

A hearing gives you the right to present your documentation to an administrative law judge who reviews the state's determination independently.

Who This Is For

  • Anyone in New York who just received a Medicaid noncompliance notice and needs a step-by-step response plan
  • Family members helping a relative respond to a notice — especially when the enrollee has limited English, a disability, or difficulty navigating the system
  • People who submitted documents but believe the state did not process them correctly
  • Enrollees who qualify for an exemption but did not report it before the noncompliance determination

Free Download

Get the New York Medicaid Work Requirement Checklist

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

Who This Is NOT For

  • People whose later NYSOH notice says coverage will stop or be reduced — request continued coverage within 10 days of the notice date and call NYSOH at 1-855-355-5777. For a local DSS action, contact OTDA at 1-800-342-3334 and request a fair hearing before the effective date in the notice
  • People who agree that they did not meet the requirement and do not have an exemption — the cure window requires proof of compliance or an exemption, not a request for more time
  • People whose Medicaid eligibility group is outside the adult expansion group — the federal work requirement applies to applicable adults in the adult expansion group or a similar specified waiver population; some people in a covered group may qualify for an exception

The Complete Response System

The New York Medicaid Work Requirement Guide includes a notice response worksheet designed for this situation: a structured form that walks you through identifying the noncompliance reason, the separate cure and appeal deadlines, the documentation you need, and the submission steps. It also includes an agency communication log for tracking every call and upload, so you have a paper trail if the state disputes what you submitted.

The guide covers the full picture — not just the noncompliance response, but the exemptions, the reporting process, and the fair hearing procedure from start to finish. If you are in the middle of a 30-day window, the notice response chapter and the fair hearing chapter are the sections to read first.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I request Aid Continuing after the 10-day deadline?

You can request an appeal within 60 days of the date on the NYSOH notice, but continued coverage after a notice stopping or reducing Medicaid requires a request within 10 days of that later notice. For a local DSS action, request a fair hearing before the effective date in the notice; if the notice was not sent before that date, OTDA says to request within 10 days of the postmark. A timely request can keep coverage in place while the appeal is pending.

What if I never received the notice?

The federal rule presumes a noncompliance notice was received 5 days after its date unless you show it arrived later. If you did not receive it on time, contact the agency named in the notice promptly and explain when it arrived; the appeal route depends on whether the decision came from NYSOH or local DSS.

Do I need a lawyer for the fair hearing?

No. You can represent yourself at a State Fair Hearing. The hearing is an administrative proceeding, not a court case. However, free legal help is available: The Legal Aid Society (NYC), NYLAG, Empire Justice Center, and Community Health Advocates all assist with Medicaid fair hearings at no cost. Having an advocate increases the chance that your documentation is presented effectively.

What happens if I win the fair hearing?

If a hearing decision is in your favor because the agency took incorrect action, Medicaid rules require the agency to make corrective payments retroactive to the date the incorrect action was taken.

Can I submit the cure documentation by mail?

Use the submission methods listed in your notice. If it allows documents to be mailed, send them to the address in the notice and keep proof of mailing. Contact the agency named in the notice to confirm receipt.

Get Your Free New York Medicaid Work Requirement Checklist

Download the New York Medicaid Work Requirement Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →