Florida Medicaid Class Action Lawsuit: What Chianne D. v. Harris Means for Your Notice
If you have received a Florida Medicaid termination notice that made no sense — a letter full of jargon, no clear reason for the decision, no breakdown of your income or the limit that applied — you are not imagining the problem. A federal court found that those notices violated your constitutional rights, and ordered Florida to fix them.
The case is Chianne D. v. Harris (formerly Chianne D. v. Weida), Case No. 3:23-cv-00985-MMH-LLL in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida. The certified class includes Florida Medicaid enrollees who were found ineligible based on income and received a notice that did not identify the individualized income used or the income standard applied.
What the Court Found
In January 2026, the district court issued a 273-page decision finding that DCF's income-based Medicaid termination notices were "exceedingly confusing and contradictory in their language and construction." The notices used identical headings for different eligibility categories, relied on impenetrable administrative codes, and failed to tell people the most basic information about why their coverage was ending.
On November 4, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit affirmed the decision and upheld a permanent injunction requiring DCF and AHCA to fix their notices.
What the Injunction Requires
Under the court's order, Florida's Medicaid termination notices must now include:
- The specific household size DCF calculated for your case — not a generic reference to "household composition."
- The countable income DCF attributed to your household — the actual dollar figure, not a reason code.
- Enough information to identify the eligibility categories DCF tested and the income limits it applied — so you can see which rules were used.
- Individualized details identifying which household member is losing coverage and why — not a blanket notice covering everyone without explanation.
Before this ruling, many termination notices contained nothing more than a vague reason code like "Over Income" with no numbers attached. Enrollees could not tell whether DCF made a calculation error because DCF never showed the calculation.
Who Is Covered by the Class
The certified class includes all Florida Medicaid enrollees who, on or after March 31, 2023, have been or will be found ineligible because income exceeded the Medicaid threshold and were issued a written notice that did not identify the individualized income used or the income standard applied. If you meet those conditions, you fall within the class.
This is a systemic case — it changed the rules for how DCF writes notices going forward. There is no claim form to fill out or individual payout. The benefit is structural: better notices, which means you can actually evaluate whether DCF's decision was correct and decide whether to appeal.
Free Download
Get the Florida Medicaid Renewal Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
What This Means for Your Renewal
If DCF terminates your Medicaid at renewal and the notice still does not clearly state your household size, your countable income, and enough information to identify the eligibility categories tested and income limits applied, the notice may not comply with the court's injunction. That matters because:
- The court found that notices meeting the class definition violated due process. If your notice lacks details required by the injunction, identify what is missing in your hearing request and continue to challenge the eligibility decision with your evidence.
- The notice date sets your deadlines. Even if a notice is poorly written, the dates on it still control the 10-day Aid Paid Pending window and the 90-day hearing deadline. Do not wait for a corrected notice — act on the deadlines and challenge the adequacy of the notice at the hearing.
- Legal aid organizations are tracking compliance. The Florida Health Justice Project and the National Health Law Program (NHeLP) were co-counsel in the case and monitor whether DCF's notices actually improve. If you receive a post-injunction notice that still lacks the required details, they want to know.
What to Do With a Bad Notice
If your termination notice does not include the specific income, household size, and threshold information required by the injunction:
- Photograph or scan the entire notice, front and back.
- File your fair hearing request within the deadlines anyway — 10 days for Aid Paid Pending, 90 days for the hearing itself. Send it to DCF's Office of Appeal Hearings at [email protected] or by mail to 2415 North Monroe Street, Suite 400-I, Tallahassee, FL 32303-4190.
- In your hearing request, note that the notice does not comply with the injunction in Chianne D. v. Harris — specifically, that it fails to state your income, the applicable standard, or which household member is affected.
- Contact legal aid. Florida Legal Services (407-801-4350) or the Florida Health Justice Project (floridahealthjustice.org) can advise whether the notice defect strengthens your case.
The Florida Medicaid Renewal guide includes a Notice of Case Action Decoder worksheet that walks through every element a valid notice must contain, so you can spot what is missing and document it before your hearing.
Get Your Free Florida Medicaid Renewal Checklist
Download the Florida Medicaid Renewal Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.